All articles28 October, 2026

How to respond to a negative Google review in NZ

what to do with negative reviews

A bad review stings, but your reply is the part you control. Here's how to respond, when to report a review, and what NZ rules say.

what to do with negative reviews

By DMS Team | Updated 25 October 2026

Reply to a negative Google review promptly and calmly, and write it for the people who will read it later. Thank the reviewer, name the actual problem, own what was yours and offer to sort it out by phone or email. Only report a review if it breaks Google's rules.

A bad review stings. But the review isn't the only thing future customers read. They read your reply too, and that part is entirely up to you.

Should you reply to a negative Google review?

Yes. A reply shows anyone reading your profile that you take problems seriously. Consumer Protection's advice to NZ businesses is blunt: "It's important not to stick your head in the sand."

A few things to know before you start:

  • You need a verified Google Business Profile to reply. Our guide to setting up a Google Business Profile in NZ covers verification.
  • Your reply is public. It shows under the review, from your business name.
  • The reviewer is notified when you reply, and they can update their review afterwards.
  • Google checks replies first. Most appear within about 10 minutes, though Google says it can occasionally take up to 30 days.

How do I reply to a negative Google review?

Keep it short. Two to four sentences is plenty. Work through these steps.

1. Take a breath and check the facts. Don't reply while you're annoyed. Look up the booking, order or job, talk to whoever was involved, and save a copy of the review.

2. Reply publicly, and promptly. Consumer Protection recommends replying publicly "with thanks, an apology, and a promise to look into it promptly." A quick reply tells everyone reading that you're paying attention.

3. Name the actual problem. "Sorry your delivery arrived late" shows you read the review. "Sorry about your experience" shows you didn't. Google also advises against sending everyone the same generic reply.

4. Own what's yours, and only what's yours. If you got it wrong, apologise plainly. Google's advice is to acknowledge your mistakes, but not to take responsibility for things outside your control.

5. Take it offline. Give a name and a phone number or email so you can sort it out privately. Reply publicly first, then move to private. That way, other readers can see you responded.

6. Fix it, or explain why not. If a remedy is fair, offer it. If you don't agree with the complaint, Consumer Protection's advice is to "set out your reasons clearly", politely and without arguing point by point.

Example: when you got it wrong

"Hi Sam, thanks for letting us know, and sorry your order turned up an hour late. That's not good enough, and we've changed how we schedule Friday deliveries. I'd like to make it right, so please call me on [phone] or email [email]. Mere, Owner"

Example: when you can't find the customer

"Hi Alex, thanks for your feedback. We can't find a booking under this name, but we'd like to look into it. Could you email [email] with your booking date so we can sort it out?"

Example: when you disagree

"Hi Jo, thanks for taking the time to write this. We're sorry the quote wasn't what you expected. Our pricing is set out before any work starts, but we're happy to go through it with you. Please call me on [phone]."

What shouldn't I do when replying to a bad review?

  • Don't argue in public. Even if you're right, a back-and-forth makes you look worse to every future customer.
  • Don't share private information. Google is clear: never share a reviewer's private details or make personal attacks.
  • Don't blame a staff member by name. Take responsibility as a business.
  • Don't paste the same reply everywhere. People notice, and Google advises against it.
  • Don't turn your reply into an ad. Google says replies shouldn't be used to offer deals.
  • Don't offer anything to change or remove a review. Offering free or discounted goods or services in exchange for removing or changing a negative review is "strictly prohibited" under Google's rules.

What happens after the reply matters too. In 2019, Hawke's Bay Today reported on a Napier cafe that replied politely to a three-star review, then banned the reviewer when she came back. The paper's editorial called the response disproportionate. A polite reply only helps if what you do next matches it.

Can I get a negative Google review removed?

Only if it breaks Google's policies, for example if it's spam, offensive, off-topic or posted by a competitor. Google says plainly: "Do not report a review just because you disagree with it or dislike it."

To report a review:

  1. Open your Business Profile and go to Reviews.
  2. Find the review and select Report.
  3. Choose the reason and send it.

Google says reports typically take several days to check. You can follow progress in Google's Reviews Management Tool. If Google decides the review doesn't break its rules, you get one appeal.

While you wait, reply anyway. A calm reply sitting under an unfair review does more for you than a blank space.

What do NZ rules say about online reviews?

The Commerce Commission's guidance is simple: "Reviews must be genuine and presented in a way that does not mislead the reader."

It enforces this. In August 2026, The TV Shop was ordered to pay $1.104 million for a range of misleading conduct. That included staff posting positive reviews of products without saying who they were, and holding back one to three star reviews unless customers responded to a follow-up email.

Google's own rules go further. Businesses must not "discourage or prohibit negative reviews, or selectively solicit positive reviews from customers." That rules out tools that send happy customers to Google and unhappy ones to a private feedback form.


How do I get more good reviews without breaking the rules?


Ask every customer, not just the happy ones. A short link or QR code from your Business Profile makes it easy.


  • Reply to good reviews too. A short, specific thank you shows real people are reading.
  • Fix what the bad reviews tell you. Patterns in complaints are free advice.
  • Don't panic about the odd bad review. Google itself says a mix of positive and negative feedback often feels more trustworthy.

Your reviews are part of your marketing

How you handle reviews shapes how people find and choose you on Google. Our 7-week SEO Strategy micro-credential covers how search works, from local listings to AI search, in live online classes with a tutor.

Want to talk through your options? 

Frequently asked questions

Should I reply to every Google review?

Ideally, yes, good and bad. Short, specific replies show you're paying attention. Avoid copy-and-paste replies.

Can I reply again if the reviewer responds?

You can edit or delete your reply at any time, and the reviewer can update their review. Rather than going back and forth in public, move the conversation to phone or email.

How long does Google take to remove a review?

Google says reports typically take several days to check. Reviews are only removed if they break Google's policies, and you get one appeal if Google decides they don't.

Can I ask a customer to change their review?

You can't offer anything in exchange for changing or removing a review. If you've fixed the problem, the reviewer is notified of your reply and can choose to update their review.

Can my staff, friends or family post reviews?

No. Reviews should reflect a genuine customer experience. Reviews from staff or people with a conflict of interest break Google's rules, and in NZ, misleading reviews can breach consumer law.